Hello, Corvallis! Meet the Cookies at Nickaly's Different Items

Hello, Corvallis! We're Nickaly's Different Items, a homemade cookie bakery right here in town. Our recipes come from three generations of family cooking, and now they're packed into every bag of cookies we bake. We make three kinds, all homemade: Brown Sugar Oatmeal, Flourless Peanut Butter and classic Sugar Cookies, in packs of 5 for $15.

Meet the Brown Sugar Oatmeal cookie

Chewy and golden, with warm brown-sugar sweetness in every bite. This is the cookie for people who think oatmeal cookies are the best cookies. (We agree.)

Meet the Flourless Peanut Butter cookie

The name tells you what makes it different: there's no flour in it — just rich, full-on peanut butter flavor in every bite. If you love peanut butter, this one's for you.

And the classic: Sugar Cookies

Buttery with a soft center — simple, sweet, and gone before you know it.

New: the Holiday Cookie Gift Box

Looking for a gift that always lands? Our Holiday Cookie Gift Box lets you pick any two packs of 5 — Brown Sugar Oatmeal, Flourless Peanut Butter, or Sugar Cookies — baked fresh and boxed up for $30.

How to get your cookies

Order at nickalysdifferentitems.com — packs of 5 for $15. In Corvallis? We deliver locally. Anywhere else in the USA? Shipping is free, and everything is baked fresh to order, Monday to Saturday, 9 AM to 5 PM. We're closed Sundays, resting up and getting ready for the week. No storefront, no market stall — just cookies from our kitchen to your door.